Offshore Trusts in BVI and Cayman
So your friends say you should “get a trust”. You would not be alone if you felt slightly flummoxed by those words. Where do you go from there?
You understand that a trust is an arrangement where party A, the trustee, holds the legal ownership in an asset but party B, the beneficiary, has the right to benefit from it. You know the trust is a very flexible arrangement which avoids probate, and that various offshore jurisdictions have combined trusts with tax neutrality and confidentiality to create quite attractive structuring solutions. But as to whether a trust is suitable for you, what kind of trust and where to put it….
The first step is to speak to your onshore lawyer. This is because such questions often depend on your onshore tax and legal considerations. However, the following will give you some pointers as to what to think about.
Firstly, which governing law to use? We may be biased but happen to think that the British Virgin Islands (“BVI”) and Cayman Islands are both excellent choices of trust jurisdiction.
- Both are British Overseas Territories. Both draw their lawyers and trust professionals largely from City firms and are on the London barristers’ circuit, and because of this retain European/US levels of professional service and responsiveness. Both are in the ‘mainstream’ of offshore jurisdictions and so are not considered controversial by banks.
- Both interlink with their other famous asset structures, removing the need to instruct lawyers in two jurisdictions if, for example, a BVI company or Cayman-registered yacht is held within a trust.
- Both are long running financial centres with sophisticated trusts legislation, including firewalls which protect the trust funds from spouses, forced heirs and creditors where the transfers into trust were not made with an intention to defraud them.
- Neither presently has a registry of trusts, though in our compliance-heavy world that could always change and the days of “planning for secrecy” are largely in the past.
Secondly, how to assign the roles? Trustees can be individuals but for residence purposes will often be professional trust companies or even private trust companies if your situation is more complex. If you want to retain a personal link you can appoint your friend or advisor as a ‘protector’, a bespoke “watchdog” role.
Thirdly, how to tailor the trust? This will depend on your needs and objectives. Trusts are endlessly flexible but can be broadly classified in a number of ways. There is the trust’s approach to its beneficiaries – its dispositive provisions. Then there is the trust’s approach to investing and managing the trust fund.
How do you want the trustee to treat the beneficiaries? Perhaps “fixed interest”: for example a trust to allow your wife an absolute right to the income and the house during her lifetime, a structure similar to a civil law usufruit. Or “discretionary”: the trustee is given flexibility to distribute among the beneficiaries as they consider best, often guided by a non-binding letter of wishes written by you. Although this option requires a leap of faith, it is very effective at removing any argument that you or the beneficiaries still retain rights over the trust fund. Or the options can be combined: for example, ‘for the sole benefit of Mr and Mrs Smith during their lifetimes and on discretionary trusts for their children thereafter’.
How does you want the trust fund to be managed? Maybe the trustee should manage it entirely, usually via delegation to an investment manager. This incurs higher fees from professional trustees but some onshore jurisdictions (e.g. South Africa) require it to demonstrate the removal of control from the client. Other clients want to continue managing trust investments themselves, either via bespoke provisions in the trust deed or via specific legislation such as the BVI’s VISTA statute which can be incorporated into the trust.
Finally, do you want this to take effect during your lifetime at all? One idea that is growing in popularity is the Will Trust – essentially, a trust written into a (very long) Will which then takes effect on death. This does not avoid probate but does avoid trustee fees during the client’s lifetime. It is used for succession planning. Perhaps your children are uninterested in the business you have built and would, you believe, sell it off, so you give it to your brother as trustee on discretionary trusts. Your letter of wishes advises your brother to reward your children for working in the company, and possibly to distribute it to them absolutely if he judges right.
We hope that the above first thoughts give you a way to unpack the endlessly flexible trust.
